| Years | President | County |
|---|---|---|
| * 1944 | Colonel Thomas M. Sherman | Nassau |
| * 1945 to 1947 | Albert W. Fleck | Erie |
| * 1947 to 1949 | Ernest Stoll | Suffolk |
| * 1949 to 1951 | Charles E. Jahne | Westchester |
| * 1951 to 1953 | Chester H. Hoffman | Erie |
| * 1953 to 1955 | Stephen P. Fox | Nassau |
| * 1955 to 1957 | Raymond A. Griffin | Monroe |
| * 1957 to 1959 | Alex Schultz | Suffolk |
| * 1959 to 1961 | James H. Holmes | Erie |
| * 1961 to 1963 | Michael J. Zerucha | Nassau |
| * 1963 to 1965 | John L. Haplin | Schenectady |
| * 1965 to 1967 | Martin Reichenberger | Monroe |
| * 1967 to 1968 | Harold P. Cahill | Suffolk |
| * 1968 to 1970 | Robert M. Jones | Erie |
| * 1970 to 1972 | Benjamin J. Moleno | Nassau |
| * 1972 to 1974 | Jack W. Dolny | Westchester |
| * 1974 to 1976 | Kenneth B. Smith | Saratoga |
| * 1976 to 1978 | William C. Johnson | Monroe |
| * 1978 to 1980 | G. Wilbur Morrell | Suffolk |
| * 1980 to 1982 | Robert H. Schultz | Erie |
| * 1982 to 1984 | Henry W. Rose | Nassau |
| * 1984 to 1986 | Albert F. Spawn | Albany |
| * 1986 to 1988 | John J. Austen | Suffolk |
| * 1988 to 1990 | Richard M. Siebert | Monroe |
| * 1990 to 1992 | John DePaoli | Westchester |
| * 1992 to 1994 | Edward "Ned" Carter | Nassau |
| * 1994 to 1996 | Ernest R. Jarvis | Albany |
| * 1996 to 1998 | James McCormick | Suffolk |
| * 1998 to 2000 | George Paul | Erie |
| 2000 to 2002 | Kenneth Hoffarth | Westchester |
| 2002 to 2004 | Frank Nocerino | Nassau |
| 2004 to 2006 | Kenneth Hoffarth | Westchester |
| 2006 to 2008 | Randall J. Rider | Erie |
| * 2008 to 2010 | Lawrence Pierce | Monroe |
| 2010 to 2012 | John Loscalzo | Suffolk |
| 2012 to 2014 | Paul Napoli | Nassau |
| 2014 to 2016 | Thomas E. Herlihy, Jr. | Onondaga |
| 2016 to 2017 | Anthony J. Gallino | Suffolk |
| 2017 to 2019 | Thomas J. Rinaldi | Saratoga |
| 2019 to 2021 | Frederick G. Senti, Jr | Nassau |
| * 2021 to 2023 | Kenneth B. Preston | Monroe |
